An Extraordinary Turn of Events: An Anti-Dystopian Novel by JC Hopkins; Science Fiction Novel is High on Character and Identity but Low on SF
By Julie Sara Porter
Bookworm Reviews
Spoilers: JC Hopkins’ An Extraordinary Turn of Events is that rare Science Fiction novel that doesn't want to be one.
With most Science Fiction novels, attention is based on world building by exploring the setting, the characters, the environment, and the problems that exist in that society. Perhaps it shows an overabundance of technology. Perhaps it's set on other worlds or planets and we get a look at some unique alien species. Perhaps we are shown a world surviving in a dystopia ruled by tyranny or a post-agrarian world trying to rebuild itself. The point is to write a Science Fiction novel, one must be creative and invest in world building. The world should not be seen as an afterthought.
When one is reading a Science Fiction novel, they shouldn't forget that they are reading a Science Fiction novel. That is the problem with An Extraordinary Turn of Events which has an interesting lead character and focuses on his personal struggles but is almost unnecessarily thrown into a futuristic setting that practically does nothing for the rest of the book.
Geronimo Vang, a writer, has been brought back from the dead by someone who has purchased his identity and now must live as him. He develops a romance with Minh Vang, no relation, a Columbia University student. As Geronimo navigates his new identity, writing career, and relationship with Minh, echoes of the original deceased Geronimo’s life appear in the form of his daughter, Dorothy and her mother, Candace.
This is a strange example of Science Fiction that tries to merge the ordinary and commonplace with the extraordinary and otherworldly. On paper, it's not a bad idea to mix genres or to focus on character rather than setting. An Extraordinary Turn of Events captures character rather well, in some ways almost too well. The book focuses on the ordinary and commonplace of Geronimo's daily life and falters in describing the extraordinary outer world in which he lives.
Many of the best moments are when we get to know Geronimo as a character. His chapters connecting with Minh are low key romantic as he tries to build a relationship with her. Both authors inspire one another with his novel based on his own experience and her YA superhero novel.
An Extraordinary Turn of Events is a story of two lost souls meeting, connecting, and going through the various stages of meeting, falling in love, living together, taking their relationship to a higher level, and arguing. They make a strong loving couple that are better together than they are apart.
There is also some real truth in Geronimo's relationship with Dorothy. Even though he is not her literal father and just has his identity, he still feels responsible for her and Candace. They are still a part of his life and while Dorothy is willing to go forward, Candace still has a lot of animosity towards the original Geronimo and the man claiming to be him. Hopkins explores real regret, guilt, and a desire to find some way to reconnect through this relationship.
When the book concentrates on real characters, it is brilliant but it falters when it tries to expand its world in Science Fiction. In the middle of these conversations with Geronimo, Minh, Dorothy, and Candace, Geronimo goes into these tangents about the dystopia in which he lives, the presence of AI, and other things that should be relevant to the plot but aren't. They aren't seen as important plot points, just meant to set the scene and remind the Reader that “Oh yeah, I forgot this is a Science Fiction novel.”
The most telling aspect of purchasing someone's identity is not elaborated upon in a way that usually would be done in such a novel. The means are such that the plot could just as easily happen through mundane means. Geronimo could have amnesia or stole his new identity and it still would have the same effect.
In fact, I imagined what the book had been like if Geronimo stole his predecessor's wallet or personal identity papers in a moment of impoverished desperation. It's not in the future just in the present and becomes a tender story of a reformed criminal trying to go legit and dealing with the consequences of his old roguish life, the current one that he is trying to remake, and the life that came with the wallet. It was better without the futuristic angle and still kept much of the character.
It's ironic that the book is titled An Extraordinary Turn of Events because the best parts of the book are well-written and deep but actually very ordinary indeed.