Monday, November 16, 2026

A Tale of Three Musicians: Ballad to the North Wind by Liz Barak; Song to the Siren by Barb Lien and Park Cooper; Mixed Tape by Geoffrey Wilson

A Tale of Three Musicians: Ballad to the North Wind by Liz Barak; Song to the Siren by Barb Lien and Park Cooper; Mixed Tape by Geoffrey Wilson 
By Julie Sara Porter
Bookworm Reviews 





Spoilers: Every year certain topics, tropes, and themes dominate the books that are reviewed on the blog. This year is no exception. We discussed sea travel as one topic. Now we move onto another more tuneful one. This time the subject that many authors liked to explore this year are music and musicians.

This year I reviewed The Girl From Melodia by Jonathan Toussaint, Where the Wave Broke by Robert Rooks, The Travel Man, and Rock Kills by Michael DiLauro. They featured inside looks at music groups with their inspirations, tours, personal struggles, and conflicts within the music industry. We Spread by Iain Reid and the  The Campaign by Evette Davis feature prominent musician characters. One of the lives sampled by Nora Seed in The Midnight Library by Matt Haig is that of a rock star (plus she works in a music store).

Well now we can add not one, not two but three books in which music and musicians play a huge part. Since they are reviewed so closely together, I decided to put them all in one entry. Each one uses a different style, literary genre, and musical inspiration to tell these stories of extremely talented and gifted people struggling with love, life, choices, fame, self-awareness, and identity. The lyrics might be different but the songs are still the same. They are about people wanting to be heard and use their appreciation or talent for music to express themselves.


Ballad to the North Wind by Liz Barak 

Ballad to the North Wind by Liz Barak deals with the stormy love life of a musician and how it inspires her creative work, affects decisions for her future, and creates emotional conflicts for decades to come. 

It's a wistful nostalgic early romance where the best emotional moments and development occur in the past. However, the present is marred by poor decisions and plot contrivances. 

Years ago indie singer/songwriter, Layla and Erik, an engineer, entered a meaningful romantic relationship despite different ages, backgrounds, interests, opinions, and future outlooks. The romance left a lasting impression on both long after it ended. 

Unfortunately the romance is recalled years later when Layla's daughter Naomi introduces Layla and her husband, David to her boyfriend Julien and his parents. Surprise, Julian's father turns out to be Erik! Don't worry, Naomi and Julian are not biologically related but that doesn't make this meeting any less awkward when Layla and Erik reunite and confront old feelings and emotions.

Most of the book is set in the past and that's where Barak shines the most. She took two characters that probably would never have encountered each other. She explored the highs and lows of their relationship and made them a loving couple at first.

Layla and Erik are a very diverse couple. Layla is a Jewish woman whose family emigrated from the Middle East. Erik is from a Protestant Glasgow background. Layla has a family history of dysfunction, neglect, abandonment, and lack of emotional closeness. Erik is from a close loving but intrusive family particularly a meddling sister. 

Layla is a young woman who had close romantic relationships but is single. Erik is approaching middle age and has one divorce in his past. Layla has an artistic creative outlook on life. Erik’s is more mathematical and analytical. They shouldn't have anything in common but they do and they share a strong love for each other.

The couple's romance is revealed through various moments of affection, conflicts, and choices that reveal much about their characters and journeys as individuals and a couple. They are shaped by their lives both before and during their union.

For example, Erik's previous marriage makes him cautious to enter another one. He is very clear about his intentions towards Layla and his future goals and how he doesn't want to have another marriage. He isn't even sure if he believes in the institution of marriage at all. 

However, the more that they get to know each other the more Erik’s resolve softens. He has to weigh whether his cynical views towards the concept of marriage itself can be altered for Layla. Maybe the institution wasn't wrong but the woman was. Maybe he just had the wrong previous partner at the wrong time. 

Unfortunately, these questions get answered in unsatisfactory ways that change his and Layla's life forever. Unfortunately, his later life leads to disappointment and more cynicisms that destroy the possibilities that might have held.

The characters also shine in their individual flashback chapters. Layla in particular fascinates during her music career and pursuit of artistic recognition. Even her name, Layla (not her birth name but given to her by an ex), comes from an old Persian romance, “Layla and Majnun” about a poet driven to madness by his forbidden love. 

Fun fact: Eric Clapton also used the story for the title of his own hit song of unrequited love for his own muse and future wife Patti Boyd. This connection among ancient romance, contemporary rock music, unrequited longing, and artistic inspiration echoes in Barak’s Layla’s own paths through love and music. 

Layla pours out her lonely childhood and unhappy relationships in her poems and songs and shares that truth with her audience. Her music is a way of revealing her deepest thoughts and emotions. Erik becomes Layla's own muse that opens her creativity. 

One of the darker aspects of her character is when she reveals that she has to suppress her musical interests to enter the mundane reality of marriage and family. She used her music as a cry for freedom and happiness. Now, life and adulthood have put a cage around her musical aspirations.

As young people, the characters are nuanced and subtle as they enter a meaningful romantic relationship that alters their perceptions of family, aspirations, friendships, and love. Unfortunately those subtleties and nuances disappear in the present when it comes to Erik, Layla, and the next generation.

The disappointment of maturity is realistic as Erik and Layla navigate disappointment and missed opportunities. They are affectionate towards their children but have regretful marriages. It's a good start in addressing regrets and disappointments but the present interactions are nowhere near as good as they were in the past. 

The subtle individual journeys and nuanced development are replaced by implausible sitcom-like hijinks that Layla and Erik fall into to keep their former relationship a secret. The interesting characters that started out so strong make foolish decisions and become less likeable in their ridiculous dishonesty.

There are implausible moments that Erik and Layla use to cover up their previous romance. Instead of just admitting that yes they knew each other upon the initial meeting when their children unite their two families, they act like they never met before. 

 Erik and Layla could have passed each other off as acquaintances, even former friends to soft peddle their former relationship and that would have been believable. Instead they act like they never met before and waste a lot of time denying any connection at all even after they reunite in private and discover their former feelings are still there. It is an unnecessary veil of secrecy when the truth, even a half-truth would have been better.

The modern situation becomes even more unbelievable when Julien and Naomi’s circle widens to include people known by their parents, people who knew Erik and Layla as a couple. Various friends and relatives for no particular motive or real reason to help them cover up their previous relationship do so causing more trouble. It's a situation that strains the reader's tolerance especially when the one person who knew they were a couple but doesn't know their kids are romantically involved or the secret conspiracy from their spouses happens to show up in the wrong place at the wrong time.

Erik and Layla started out as understandable and likeable but the present story strips that away. Instead they become two people who are in danger of hurting their children and themselves with unnecessary deception. A romance that began in the sweet rhythm of nostalgia ends on a sour modern note.


 


Song to the Siren by Barb Lien and Park Cooper 

Song to the Siren is a mesmerizing Paranormal Horror about the intoxicating world of rock music, fame, obsession, and the line between sanity and madness, passion and obsession, reality and illusion.

Ryan Torres and Brandon Hawkins, two documentary filmmakers, are investigating the mysterious life and death of Reed Sinclair, indie rock singer and musician and front man of the band, Big Carnival. They get a coveted interview with Samantha “Sam Mac” McNamara, photographer and Reed's life partner. She sits the filmmakers down and tells the story of her consuming, devoted, but toxic relationship with Reed and the darker separate path that he took, a path of madness and fear as he feels haunted by Belle, a beautiful mysterious creature that he believes has cursed him since childhood. 

Song to the Siren straddles a fine line between fantasy and reality. It stands as both a realistic all too human story about the rise and fall of a rock star and a dark fantasy about an alluring demonic being gaining complete control over a helpless mortal victim. This book succeeds brilliantly at both aspects combining these two different themes into one whole work. 

The narration is an offbeat choice that actually works. Most authors would tell the book through Reed's point of view and it would work. We would get to the root of his obsession, artistic inspiration, relationship with Sam, and his journey through the highs and lows of the rock music scene. It would be fine but Lien and Cooper choose to tell the story from an outside perspective with Sam’s narration instead.

Normally it would be off putting to read the perspective of the main protagonist’s observer, a friend, or love interest instead of their own. But it actually works in this case because it keeps us physically and emotionally separated from Reed. We are learning about Reed at the same time as the filmmakers. 

Sam is protective of her partner in life and death and is clearly worried about how others will perceive him. She gives us the pertinent information about Reed when she is good and ready to give it and not a moment sooner.

We see Reed as Sam sees him and how their relationship developed over the years. As children, they saved one another from loneliness. Reed's dysfunctional family closed off after the death of his older brother in Vietnam. Sam was too tomboyish and brash for her more traditional mother. Reed and Sam became a surrogate brother and sister. 

The surrogate sibling relationship between Reed and Sam fills the void that their families didn't always provide. Reed finds a best friend that he can share most of his private thoughts and secrets with. Sam finds someone who respects her appearance and personality and doesn't try to change her. They share their artistic pursuits, his for music and hers for visual arts and eventually photography, as means of expressing themselves and building bridges of understanding between them. 

As Sam and Reed grow up, that relationship deepens. They become each other's confidant, sounding board, muse, secret keeper, best friend, lover, and soul mate. Through Sam’s narration, we see her and Reed's relationship evolve profoundly especially as Reed's obsession with Belle overwhelms him. 

Sam's narrative purposely keeps Reed separated from us and from Sam as well as she tries to understand his troubled mind especially as far as Belle is concerned. Since Reed doesn't tell most of the story, we don't get a full picture of who Belle is. Sam catches glimpses of a red haired woman but she can't tell if it's real or not. The closest that we get is a portrait of a beautiful red haired fairy that hangs in the Sinclair home. It is a portrait of “La Belle Dame Sans Merci,” John Keats’ poem about a beautiful siren-like creature that lures men to their deaths and for which Belle herself is named. 

 Sometimes when Sam and Reed are alone, Reed suddenly yells at something invisible and orders it to go away. In one chilling chapter, a confrontation between Reed and his invisible assailant ends with him falling from a tree in a suicide attempt to end the mental torture.

Sam isn't even sure if Belle is real or whether Reed is mentally ill. He is a musician after all and don't many creatives have mental health issues and explore darker themes? Could that be what's at play here? We don't know and since we are hearing about Reed from Sam's perspective and not his, we can't ask him We are forced to guess whether Reed is haunted by a mythological creature or the terrors of his own mind

The other reason that the narration works is because it plays into the whole idea of creative inspiration. This creativity served as potential answers about Reed's condition. It's no coincidence that the interviews are centered around an upcoming documentary film.

 It gives Ryan and Brandon opportunities to share their own musical memories of Big Carnival. They wonder about the meaning and inspiration behind Reed's lyrics and the creative process that led to his music. Sam gives her own perspectives and interpretations on where his music came from. 

Anyone who has listened to a song, read a book, watched a movie, or looked at a painting brings their own interpretation and meaning to the work. They search for symbols, motifs, and themes that connect with their interpretation. Maybe they have a personal experience or a memory associated with the work. 

That is what is happening between Sam and the filmmakers. As Sam untangles the story of her, Reed, and Belle, she demystifies Reed's songs and gives them context of what he was going through when they were written.

 It's an emotional trajectory into Reed's mindset that starts out energetic, light, and soft. Eventually when Belle becomes more of an obsession, Reed's songs carry themes of dark fantasy, black magic, imprisonment, and a splintering mind unable to separate the fantasies that Belle represents from the reality that Sam lives in.

 Sam can't see or talk to Belle but she can see that Belle's fingerprints are all over Reed's soul and art. All Sam can do is hear the music, understand the lyrics, interpret their meaning, and recognize the cry for help when Reed gives it. 

It's worth noting that in mythology, characters like Belle, usually fairies, sorceresses, shapeshifters, mer creatures or other types are known for their bewitching beauty, leaving their mortal lovers insane or depressed, and inspiring artists. That is what Belle does.She draws Reed through her presence, drives him to madness and suspicion, and becomes a source for his music. 

Whether Belle actually exists or not is immaterial. If she's real then she's following that process of “La Belle Dame” perfectly. If she's not, then Reed's mind is devoured by a character that he himself created from myth and legend. 

There is a deeper subtext with Belle. She could also be a personification of the creative impulse that exists within all artists. The one that inspires them to work on their chosen art form and forego family, friends, and loved ones.

This impulse is consuming, obsessive, and keeps the artist working constantly. Nothing is more important than feeding it. Sometimes that creativity comes with extra baggage like addiction, mental illness, dysfunction, burn out, and an early death. 

That creative impulse draws you in, envelopes you, and if you aren't too careful it can swallow you whole. 


Mixed Tape by Geoffrey Wilson 

Unlike the other two books, Will, the protagonist of Geoffrey Wilson’s Mixed Tape, is not a musician but he grew up during a time when he was surrounded by pop and rock music that he related to his own struggles. In fact, music is a surrounding theme throughout the book as Will struggles with his sexuality and identity during the AIDS crisis of the 1980’s.

AIDS first enters the conversation during a car ride with his friends on New Years Eve 1981 when a brief news report mentions that a new virus has been found and identified in the United States that seems to affect only gay men or drug addicts. Will’s classmates dismiss and ignore it but the news worries him. He is struggling with his own erotic thoughts about male celebrities and classmates. Even though he hasn't dated anyone, he knows that he is attracted to guys. The last thing that he wants is a virus singling out people like him and making looking for love harder.

Will is a compelling lead for such a bildungsroman. He starts out so uncertain of himself that he can't even summon the words to say that he's gay. He stammers, hides, and runs away to avoid confronting his true feelings. He finds the closet to be too confining but too secure for him to come out of it.

From 1982-1990, AIDS spread and claimed victims numbering in the thousands. Will ages from high school to college and has to come to terms with being gay during a time of illness and rigid Conservatism. Besides those fears, Will also has anxieties of becoming romantically involved and entering a long-term relationship. Then there is his worry over whether any sexual encounter could result in long term illness or at the time a death sentence. 

These fears cause Will to retreat inward and wordlessly concede and capitulate to situations that he shouldn't. He bites his tongue when his father expresses disgust that Canadian public health care should go to “those people to fund their lifestyles” (unaware that his own son is one of those people). He works for a time for a Conservative MP and regrettably steps aside when his boss's policies affect people like him personally. He lives in a self-imposed prison of shame and self-loathing that is manufactured by an intolerant world. 

Despite being in the closet, Will has collected newspaper clippings of the HIV virus since 1982. Besides keeping him informed of this deadly virus, it becomes a link to people like him and an aide to help him understand the struggles that other gay men face. Later as AIDS is spread through his native Canada and affects him personally does he realize that keeping the clippings gives life and meaning to people who would otherwise have been ignored by people. Without realizing it, he had been paying tribute to the gay community all along.

He also develops a pretty active social romantic life despite being in the closet. His potential dates with girls fail miserably because he feels like a fraud who is lying to them and won't compromise his hope for a romantic long term relationship. He lusts after his roommate despite his heterosexuality. In one chilling chapter, he is practically raped by a colleague in Ottawa who won't take no for an answer.

By far Will's strongest relationships are with two different men: Chris and Tom. They represent different possibilities for his future. Chris inspires a romantic side in Will that he finally finds someone to open his heart to and be honest. Tom is an LGBT+ and AIDS awareness advocate. Through him, Will sees someone who isn't afraid of being himself, someone with courage that he denied for himself.

As previously mentioned, this book is filled with music. Each chapter title is named for a song that is associated with Will's various struggles. For example Tina Turner’s “What's Love Got to Do With It?” appears as Will tries to protect his health and heart from being hurt by not dating seriously. The Eurythmics’ “Would I Lie To You?” is the chapter title in which Will lies to a potential date, his father, friends, and himself about whether or not he is gay. Cyndi Lauper’s “True Colors” is the chapter where Will realizes that he is falling in love with Chris.

Chris also makes Will a mixed tape of songs that he connects with their relationship. The chapter titles and references to the songs on the mixed tape suggest that the reader is shown a soundtrack of Will's inner soul and private thoughts. These, the AIDS newspaper clippings, and the relationships between Will and other men are the only times when Will truly feels honest with himself. These become gateways to Will's journey from the closet to self-awareness, understanding, and personal freedom.


No comments:

Post a Comment